[OH] Do I get premium pay for every hour on consecutive workdays under my union contract?

16
4
Queeneth E. Esq
Queeneth E. Esq

5,738 satisfied customers

View context
Solved

Being in Ohio changes the statutory background, but it does not materially change how I read the union-contract language.

Volunteering probably does not eliminate the premium. Your agreement to cover the extra day ordinarily means you agreed to work the shift. It does not necessarily mean you agreed to work it at a lower rate than the collective bargaining agreement requires.

The consecutive-days clause says “All hours of work” on the applicable consecutive day shall receive the premium.

It refers to a day of “actual work” and does not say the premium applies only when:
The employer forces or mandates the shift;
The employee does not volunteer;
The shift is involuntarily assigned; or
The employee is called in unexpectedly.

Therefore, assuming the employer accepted your offer and scheduled or authorized you to work, the fact that you volunteered should not by itself remove the fifth-day premium.

An individual employee generally cannot make an arrangement with the employer that diminishes benefits established by the collective bargaining agreement merely by accepting work. The Supreme Court has recognized that individual employment arrangements cannot be used to reduce an employer’s obligations concerning matters covered by a collective agreement (J.I. Case Co. v. NLRB, 321 U.S. 332 (1944)).

Ohio law generally requires time-and-one-half only for hours exceeding 40 in one workweek (Ohio Revised Code § 4111.03(A)). Unlike California, Ohio law does not generally require overtime merely because an employee worked more than eight or ten hours in one day or worked a fifth or sixth consecutive day.

Thus, there are two separate potential rights:
Ohio/FLSA right: Six hours at 1.5× if you work 46 hours.
Union-contract right: Potentially all ten hours on your fifth consecutive day at 1.5×.

Federal wage law (Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. § 207) establishes minimum protections but allows collective bargaining agreements to provide higher overtime premiums or shorter qualifying workweeks. It does not relieve the employer of its contractual obligations under the CBA.

The complete provision says that all hours on the sixth consecutive day are paid at time-and-one-half, followed by “time and one-half beginning the fifth (5th) consecutive day within a work week for an employee regularly assigned to work ten (10) hour shifts.”

That parenthetical appears to substitute fifth day for sixth day when the employee is regularly assigned ten-hour shifts.

Suppose you have 36 worked hours before the extra shift:
Fifth consecutive day: 10 additional hours
Total: 46 hours
Contractual argument: All 10 hours at 1.5×
Employer’s interpretation: First four hours straight time and final six at 1.5×

Your interpretation is stronger based on “all hours of work” and “beginning the fifth consecutive day.” If the parties intended only ordinary weekly overtime after 40 hours, the special fifth-day language would add little or nothing to the general overtime provision.

Your employer might have a defensible contrary position only if another part of the CBA says something such as:
Voluntary overtime is treated differently from assigned overtime;
Employee-requested shifts or shift trades do not qualify for consecutive-day premiums;
Premium pay applies only to employer-mandated assignments;
Employees may waive consecutive-day premiums when requesting additional work;
A separate overtime-distribution article controls voluntary coverage.

Also check for provisions titled:
Overtime Equalization
Voluntary Overtime
Shift Trades
Extra Shifts
Premium Pay
No Pyramiding
Management Rights
Past Practice

A no-pyramiding clause would normally prevent receiving two separate overtime premiums for the same hours. It would not necessarily convert the whole fifth day into ordinary straight time. (Federal regulations treat contractual premiums for sixth- or seventh-day work and for hours beyond a daily or weekly standard as true overtime premiums that can be credited toward statutory weekly overtime; see 29 C.F.R. § 778.202.)

The “over forty hours” condition: There is some ambiguity because the consecutive-day clause says the premium applies “provided the Employee has worked over forty hours in the work week.”

Your strongest interpretation is that once you finish the week with 46 actual hours, the condition is satisfied and all hours on the qualifying fifth day receive the premium.

The employer may argue that the premium begins only once you cross 40 hours. However, that interpretation conflicts with “all hours of work” and “beginning the fifth consecutive day.” This is exactly the type of contract-interpretation dispute that should go through the CBA grievance process.

Confirm the extra shift in writing:

“I am confirming that management approved and scheduled me to cover the additional ten-hour shift due to the employee’s leave. This will be my fifth consecutive day of actual work within the workweek and will bring me to 46 hours. Under the consecutive-days provision applicable to employees regularly assigned ten-hour shifts, I understand that all hours worked on the fifth consecutive day are paid at time-and-one-half. Please advise immediately if the company interprets the provision differently and identify the contractual language supporting that interpretation.”

Send the same information to your union steward or representative now rather than waiting indefinitely for payroll. Ask for:
The official workweek boundaries;
Confirmation that you are “regularly assigned” ten-hour shifts;
The grievance deadline;
Prior examples involving voluntary fifth-day coverage; and
Any arbitration decisions interpreting this exact clause

Volunteering to cover the person’s leave probably does not waive the fifth-consecutive-day premium. If all five days fall within the same defined workweek and you exceed 40 actual worked hours, you have a substantial CBA argument for all ten hours on day five at time-and-one-half, although the union grievance and arbitration procedure may ultimately control the interpretation.

Employee Complaint Form

Full conversation

I have a question on my work contract regarding overtime vs. a consecutive day clause.

user
Lexi
Lexi, Chatbot

I understand that navigating work contracts can be challenging. Can you tell me if you are currently employed or in the process of negotiating a new contract?

Currently employed.

user
Lexi
Lexi, Chatbot

Have you already discussed your concerns about the overtime and consecutive day clause with your employer or HR department?

Yes, I was told they are the same thing, but I wanted someone else’s opinion.

user
Lexi
Lexi, Chatbot

Is there anything else the Employment Lawyer should know before I connect you? Rest assured they’ll be able to help with your work contract.

Overtime: All hours worked in excess of either eight (8) consecutive hours (or ten (10) consecutive hours for those employees scheduled for four (4) ten (10) hour days) in any one (1) work day or in excess of forty (40) hours in a work week, shall be paid at the rate of time and one-half the regular rate of pay. All hours worked from the beginning of the thirteenth (13) hour in any one (1) work day shall be paid at the rate of double (2 times) the regular rate of pay. Employees are not permitted to work overtime (daily or weekly) unless it is pre-approved by their approval manager. Employees who do so may be subject to disciplinary action. Employees are not to perform station-related work during unscheduled work times without prior express authorization from the Employee’s supervisor. This includes work performed before or after the employee’s scheduled work hours.

user
Queeneth E. Esq
Queeneth E. Esq

Hello and welcome to our service. My name is Queeneth. I am an attorney with over 8 years of legal experience. I will do my best to assist you today. First, I need to ask you a few questions to give you the best answer. (Kindly note that our conversation does not establish an attorney-client relationship.)

Sounds good!

user

Here are both clauses. Not sure why they both didn’t send the first time.

Overtime: All hours worked in excess of either eight (8) consecutive hours (or ten (10) consecutive hours for those employees scheduled for four (4) ten (10) hour days) in any one (1) work day or in excess of forty (40) hours in a work week, shall be paid at the rate of time and one-half the regular rate of pay. All hours worked from the beginning of the thirteenth (13) hour in any one (1) work day shall be paid at the rate of double (2 times) the regular rate of pay. Employees are not permitted to work overtime (daily or weekly) unless it is pre-approved by their approval manager. Employees who do so may be subject to disciplinary action. Employees are not to perform station-related work during unscheduled work times without prior express authorization from the Employee’s supervisor. This includes work performed before or after the employee’s scheduled work hours.

Consecutive days: All hours of work on an Employee’s sixth (6th) consecutive day of actual work within a work week shall be paid for at the rate of time and one-half, provided the Employee has worked over forty (40) hours in the work week in which the sixth (6th) day falls (time and one-half beginning the fifth (5th) consecutive day within a work week for an employee regularly assigned to work ten (10) hour shifts). All hours worked on the Employee’s seventh (7th) consecutive day of actual work within a work week shall be paid at the rate of double time, provided the Employee has worked over forty (40) hours in the work week in which the seventh (7th) consecutive day falls. Overtime shall be computed in one-quarter (1/4) hour segments. It is not the Company’s intention to schedule back-to-back five (5) consecutive day work schedules.

user
Queeneth E. Esq
Queeneth E. Esq

Thank you for the feedback. Please allow me some time to prepare a response. I will get back to you shortly.

I work 10-hour shifts. This work week, tomorrow will be my 5th consecutive day and will put me at 46 hours this week. Would I be able to claim the consecutive day benefit? Or would I just get the overtime for the 6 hours over 40?

user

I’m in Ohio, and it is a union contract. Would agreeing to work the extra days change anything? We had someone go on leave, and I said I could work it.

user
Queeneth E. Esq
Queeneth E. Esq

Being in Ohio changes the statutory background, but it does not materially change how I read the union-contract language.

Volunteering probably does not eliminate the premium. Your agreement to cover the extra day ordinarily means you agreed to work the shift. It does not necessarily mean you agreed to work it at a lower rate than the collective bargaining agreement requires.

The consecutive-days clause says “All hours of work” on the applicable consecutive day shall receive the premium.

It refers to a day of “actual work” and does not say the premium applies only when:
The employer forces or mandates the shift;
The employee does not volunteer;
The shift is involuntarily assigned; or
The employee is called in unexpectedly.

Therefore, assuming the employer accepted your offer and scheduled or authorized you to work, the fact that you volunteered should not by itself remove the fifth-day premium.

An individual employee generally cannot make an arrangement with the employer that diminishes benefits established by the collective bargaining agreement merely by accepting work. The Supreme Court has recognized that individual employment arrangements cannot be used to reduce an employer’s obligations concerning matters covered by a collective agreement (J.I. Case Co. v. NLRB, 321 U.S. 332 (1944)).

Ohio law generally requires time-and-one-half only for hours exceeding 40 in one workweek (Ohio Revised Code § 4111.03(A)). Unlike California, Ohio law does not generally require overtime merely because an employee worked more than eight or ten hours in one day or worked a fifth or sixth consecutive day.

Thus, there are two separate potential rights:
Ohio/FLSA right: Six hours at 1.5× if you work 46 hours.
Union-contract right: Potentially all ten hours on your fifth consecutive day at 1.5×.

Federal wage law (Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. § 207) establishes minimum protections but allows collective bargaining agreements to provide higher overtime premiums or shorter qualifying workweeks. It does not relieve the employer of its contractual obligations under the CBA.

The complete provision says that all hours on the sixth consecutive day are paid at time-and-one-half, followed by “time and one-half beginning the fifth (5th) consecutive day within a work week for an employee regularly assigned to work ten (10) hour shifts.”

That parenthetical appears to substitute fifth day for sixth day when the employee is regularly assigned ten-hour shifts.

Suppose you have 36 worked hours before the extra shift:
Fifth consecutive day: 10 additional hours
Total: 46 hours
Contractual argument: All 10 hours at 1.5×
Employer’s interpretation: First four hours straight time and final six at 1.5×

Your interpretation is stronger based on “all hours of work” and “beginning the fifth consecutive day.” If the parties intended only ordinary weekly overtime after 40 hours, the special fifth-day language would add little or nothing to the general overtime provision.

Your employer might have a defensible contrary position only if another part of the CBA says something such as:
Voluntary overtime is treated differently from assigned overtime;
Employee-requested shifts or shift trades do not qualify for consecutive-day premiums;
Premium pay applies only to employer-mandated assignments;
Employees may waive consecutive-day premiums when requesting additional work;
A separate overtime-distribution article controls voluntary coverage.

Also check for provisions titled:
Overtime Equalization
Voluntary Overtime
Shift Trades
Extra Shifts
Premium Pay
No Pyramiding
Management Rights
Past Practice

A no-pyramiding clause would normally prevent receiving two separate overtime premiums for the same hours. It would not necessarily convert the whole fifth day into ordinary straight time. (Federal regulations treat contractual premiums for sixth- or seventh-day work and for hours beyond a daily or weekly standard as true overtime premiums that can be credited toward statutory weekly overtime; see 29 C.F.R. § 778.202.)

The “over forty hours” condition: There is some ambiguity because the consecutive-day clause says the premium applies “provided the Employee has worked over forty hours in the work week.”

Your strongest interpretation is that once you finish the week with 46 actual hours, the condition is satisfied and all hours on the qualifying fifth day receive the premium.

The employer may argue that the premium begins only once you cross 40 hours. However, that interpretation conflicts with “all hours of work” and “beginning the fifth consecutive day.” This is exactly the type of contract-interpretation dispute that should go through the CBA grievance process.

Confirm the extra shift in writing:

“I am confirming that management approved and scheduled me to cover the additional ten-hour shift due to the employee’s leave. This will be my fifth consecutive day of actual work within the workweek and will bring me to 46 hours. Under the consecutive-days provision applicable to employees regularly assigned ten-hour shifts, I understand that all hours worked on the fifth consecutive day are paid at time-and-one-half. Please advise immediately if the company interprets the provision differently and identify the contractual language supporting that interpretation.”

Send the same information to your union steward or representative now rather than waiting indefinitely for payroll. Ask for:
The official workweek boundaries;
Confirmation that you are “regularly assigned” ten-hour shifts;
The grievance deadline;
Prior examples involving voluntary fifth-day coverage; and
Any arbitration decisions interpreting this exact clause

Volunteering to cover the person’s leave probably does not waive the fifth-consecutive-day premium. If all five days fall within the same defined workweek and you exceed 40 actual worked hours, you have a substantial CBA argument for all ten hours on day five at time-and-one-half, although the union grievance and arbitration procedure may ultimately control the interpretation.

Got it! Thank you so much!

user
Queeneth E. Esq
Queeneth E. Esq

You’re welcome. Thank you for using our service.

Disclaimer


By messaging FreeLegalAdvice.com, you agree to our Terms and have read our Privacy Policy.

The information provided on AskaLawyer.com is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and timeliness of the information presented, we make no guarantees regarding its completeness or applicability to your specific circumstances.

Use of this website does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and FreeLegalAdvice.com or any of its attorneys. Communications through this website, including any responses from attorneys, are not privileged or confidential. For advice tailored to your individual situation, we recommend consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.

FreeLegalAdvice.com disclaims any liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this site. We are not responsible for any third-party content that may be accessed through this website. Reliance on any information provided herein is solely at your own risk.

Free Legal Advice Logo
Free Legal Advice Logo
Intake Questions
Question  of 3
Loading...

Lexi, Chatbot

Would you like to chat with a licensed attorney?

Online

Yes
No

Would you like to continue with unlimited answers from legal-specific AI?

Legal AI

Using ChatGPT 4o

Yes
No
Loading...

How do you like to pay?

By proceeding with payment, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy. You authorize us to charge $ today and $ thereafter until canceled. You may cancel anytime in the My Account section to stop future charges.

Total Due:

Processing...

After purchasing, your chat will begin with an attorney.

By proceeding with payment, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy. You authorize us to charge $ today and $ thereafter until canceled. You may cancel anytime in the My Account section to stop future charges.

Total Due:

After purchasing, your chat will begin with an attorney.

It looks like you already have an account with Free Legal Advice.

We have sent you a magic link to . Click the link in your email to sign in and continue your chat.

spin

Step of 6 •

You'll receive an email at as soon as the lawyer joins the conversation 🙏🏻😊

Over 90% of lawyers connect within 5 minutes. If you're not online at that moment, don't worry — the lawyer will reply to your message while you're away.

You're also welcome to stay in the chat while waiting to be connected 💬✨

Waiting for lawyer

You've reached your AI chat limit

Talk to a real lawyer to get expert legal advice tailored to your situation.

Your lawyer will reply as soon as possible

If there’s a delay, please don’t worry. Your chat will stay open, and they’ll get back to you as soon as they can. There’s no rush on your end either. You’ll receive an email notification as soon as there’s a new message.

What's your legal question?