[FL] How should an employee respond when pressured to resign without any documented performance issues?

16
5
Lawyer, Esquire
Lawyer, Esquire

25 satisfied customers

View context
Solved

Saying you were “considering resignation” is not usually the same as actually resigning, especially since you never gave notice or submitted the resignation form. However, the company could still try to characterize the separation that way, so the exact wording of your communications will matter for severance, bonus rights, and Florida reemployment assistance (FL Stat § 443.101(1)(a)).

The current facts do not clearly establish constructive discharge. That generally requires working conditions so intolerable that a reasonable employee would feel forced to resign. Pressure to resign or face “other options” may be relevant, but it is not automatically enough.

In the meeting, you can clearly state that you have not resigned, do not intend to resign voluntarily, remain willing to work, and are willing to review any company-proposed separation terms in writing. Afterward, send a short email confirming what was discussed, any deadlines given, and that you remain employed and available to work unless told otherwise.

Your health disclosures may be relevant, but saying the job was harming your health does not necessarily amount to an ADA accommodation request (42 U.S.C. § 12112(b)(5)(A)). The company generally must understand that you need a workplace change or leave because of a medical condition. Retaliation also usually requires protected activity, such as requesting an accommodation or raising disability discrimination concerns (42 U.S.C. § 12203).

You appear likely to meet the length-of-employment requirement for FMLA, but eligibility also depends on hours worked and whether the employer and worksite are covered (29 U.S.C. § 2611(2)). You do not have to use the term “FMLA,” but you generally must provide enough information for the employer to understand that leave may be needed for a qualifying medical reason. General statements about stress or health effects may not be enough by themselves.

Whether to request accommodation or medical leave now depends on whether you actually need it medically. A legitimate request may affect the company’s obligations and could become relevant in separation negotiations, but it does not automatically increase severance value. Any proposed release should be reviewed before signing because it may waive employment, disability, leave, bonus, and other claims.

Employment Separation (Severance) Agreement

Full conversation

I’m a Director of Software Development with about nine years at an Illinois-headquartered company; I live and work in Florida. A few weeks ago I told HR and my manager I was considering resignation and asked what a transition might look like, but I never resigned, gave notice, or submitted the resignation template they sent me. They’ve since told me it would be best for both sides if I resign, citing unspecified peer concerns about collaboration, with no examples, no documented performance issues, and no PIP. Separately, over the past several months I’d repeatedly told my manager the job was harming my health. They’ve now scheduled a meeting for tomorrow afternoon demanding an answer on whether I intend to resign. I don’t want to resign. I want to understand my leverage and negotiate a separation, and I need help before that meeting.

user
Lexi
Lexi, Chatbot

I understand how stressful this situation must be for you. Have you had any formal performance reviews or documented feedback from your employer regarding your work?

Yes, but all my reviews are positive, no indication of performance concerns.

user
Lexi
Lexi, Chatbot

Have you discussed your health concerns with HR or received any accommodations related to your job?

I’ve only discussed my concerns with my manager, there haven’t been any accommodations

user
Lexi
Lexi, Chatbot

Is there anything else the Employment Lawyer should know before I connect you? Rest assured they’ll be able to help with your resignation negotiation.

No.

user
Lawyer, Esquire
Lawyer, Esquire

Hey there! Welcome to our service. I’m Kelly M., an attorney with many years of experience. Just so you are aware, our service is a legal information-only site. No attorney-client relationship is formed from our conversation. I see you’re dealing with a situation where your employer is pressuring you to resign without documented performance issues. Have you considered discussing your health concerns with HR or seeking legal advice on negotiating a separation?

Hi, I discussed my health concerns with my manager, but not HR. I am interested in negotiating a separation.

user
Lawyer, Esquire
Lawyer, Esquire

Do you have any documentation or written communication regarding the health concerns you discussed with your manager? This could be important for your negotiation.

There is no documentation of the health concerns. There is really no documentation for anything related to this matter.

user
Lawyer, Esquire
Lawyer, Esquire

Based on what you described, the company can generally terminate an at-will employee without first using a PIP or documenting performance problems, unless an employment contract or unlawful reason is involved. Your positive reviews and the lack of prior concerns may still give you leverage in negotiating severance.

Telling your manager that the job was affecting your health may matter, but it does not automatically create a legal claim. That would depend on the nature of the health issue, what the company understood, and whether you were asking for leave or a workplace change.

You do not have to resign simply because the company prefers that outcome. Since you want to negotiate a separation, the main issues are severance, continued benefits, bonus or equity treatment, reference language, any restrictive covenants, a release of claims, and whether the company describes the separation as a resignation or termination. That wording can also affect unemployment eligibility.

For tomorrow’s meeting, you can listen, avoid agreeing to resign on the spot, and ask for any proposed separation terms in writing so you can review them.

Does my earlier statement that I was “considering resignation,” combined with HR providing a resignation template, create meaningful risk that the company can characterize this as a voluntary resignation, for severance eligibility, bonus, and Florida reemployment assistance purposes? Am I in constructive discharge / forced resignation territory given the “resign or we’ll consider other options” framing? How should I respond in tomorrow’s meeting and in writing afterward?

Do my repeated disclosures to my manager about health impacts, followed within months by pressure to resign with no documented performance process, support a disability discrimination, failure-to-accommodate, or retaliation claim under the ADA and/or the Florida Civil Rights Act? 5. Am I FMLA-eligible, and does anything I said constitute a request for leave or accommodation sufficient to trigger the employer’s obligations? 6. Should I be pursuing accommodation or medical leave now, and how does that interact with the separation discussion? 7. When and how should this be raised with the company, and does raising it change what my release is worth?

user

I was going to send this email ahead of my meeting:

Thanks for the follow-up. I wanted to put a short summary in writing, since I think there may be a misunderstanding from our earlier conversation. In our meeting on [redacted: meeting date], I raised the possibility of a transition and asked what one might look like. I was exploring options. I did not resign, give notice, or state a decision to leave, and I have not submitted the resignation template that HR provided. I remain fully engaged in my role. On the collaboration concerns that were mentioned, I haven’t been given specific examples, documented performance feedback, or a performance improvement plan. If there are specifics and clear expectations, I’d welcome them in writing so I can address them directly. If instead the company has concluded that it wants to end our employment relationship, I understand, and I’m prepared to handle that professionally and make the transition as smooth as possible. In that case I’d ask that we discuss the terms of a mutual separation. Regarding the suggestion that I provide 30-60 days’ notice: since I’m not resigning, a notice period wouldn’t apply. If the company would like me to work through a defined transition period, I’m open to that, and we can document it as part of the broader discussion. I don’t intend to submit a resignation, as it wouldn’t accurately reflect the situation. But I’m happy to keep talking about what makes sense for both sides.

user
Lawyer, Esquire
Lawyer, Esquire

Saying you were “considering resignation” is not usually the same as actually resigning, especially since you never gave notice or submitted the resignation form. However, the company could still try to characterize the separation that way, so the exact wording of your communications will matter for severance, bonus rights, and Florida reemployment assistance (FL Stat § 443.101(1)(a)).

The current facts do not clearly establish constructive discharge. That generally requires working conditions so intolerable that a reasonable employee would feel forced to resign. Pressure to resign or face “other options” may be relevant, but it is not automatically enough.

In the meeting, you can clearly state that you have not resigned, do not intend to resign voluntarily, remain willing to work, and are willing to review any company-proposed separation terms in writing. Afterward, send a short email confirming what was discussed, any deadlines given, and that you remain employed and available to work unless told otherwise.

Your health disclosures may be relevant, but saying the job was harming your health does not necessarily amount to an ADA accommodation request (42 U.S.C. § 12112(b)(5)(A)). The company generally must understand that you need a workplace change or leave because of a medical condition. Retaliation also usually requires protected activity, such as requesting an accommodation or raising disability discrimination concerns (42 U.S.C. § 12203).

You appear likely to meet the length-of-employment requirement for FMLA, but eligibility also depends on hours worked and whether the employer and worksite are covered (29 U.S.C. § 2611(2)). You do not have to use the term “FMLA,” but you generally must provide enough information for the employer to understand that leave may be needed for a qualifying medical reason. General statements about stress or health effects may not be enough by themselves.

Whether to request accommodation or medical leave now depends on whether you actually need it medically. A legitimate request may affect the company’s obligations and could become relevant in separation negotiations, but it does not automatically increase severance value. Any proposed release should be reviewed before signing because it may waive employment, disability, leave, bonus, and other claims.

Lawyer, Esquire
Lawyer, Esquire

I hope the information I provided was helpful! Since I did not hear anything further from you, I will close out this request for now. I wish you well and hope you are able to resolve your issue.

Disclaimer


By messaging FreeLegalAdvice.com, you agree to our Terms and have read our Privacy Policy.

The information provided on AskaLawyer.com is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and timeliness of the information presented, we make no guarantees regarding its completeness or applicability to your specific circumstances.

Use of this website does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and FreeLegalAdvice.com or any of its attorneys. Communications through this website, including any responses from attorneys, are not privileged or confidential. For advice tailored to your individual situation, we recommend consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.

FreeLegalAdvice.com disclaims any liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this site. We are not responsible for any third-party content that may be accessed through this website. Reliance on any information provided herein is solely at your own risk.

Free Legal Advice Logo
Free Legal Advice Logo
Intake Questions
Question  of 3
Loading...

Lexi, Chatbot

Would you like to chat with a licensed attorney?

Online

Yes
No

Would you like to continue with unlimited answers from legal-specific AI?

Legal AI

Using ChatGPT 4o

Yes
No
Loading...

How do you like to pay?

By proceeding with payment, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy. You authorize us to charge $ today and $ thereafter until canceled. You may cancel anytime in the My Account section to stop future charges.

Total Due:

Processing...

After purchasing, your chat will begin with an attorney.

By proceeding with payment, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy. You authorize us to charge $ today and $ thereafter until canceled. You may cancel anytime in the My Account section to stop future charges.

Total Due:

After purchasing, your chat will begin with an attorney.

It looks like you already have an account with Free Legal Advice.

We have sent you a magic link to . Click the link in your email to sign in and continue your chat.

spin

Step of 6 •

You'll receive an email at as soon as the lawyer joins the conversation 🙏🏻😊

Over 90% of lawyers connect within 5 minutes. If you're not online at that moment, don't worry — the lawyer will reply to your message while you're away.

You're also welcome to stay in the chat while waiting to be connected 💬✨

Waiting for lawyer

You've reached your AI chat limit

Talk to a real lawyer to get expert legal advice tailored to your situation.

Your lawyer will reply as soon as possible

If there’s a delay, please don’t worry. Your chat will stay open, and they’ll get back to you as soon as they can. There’s no rush on your end either. You’ll receive an email notification as soon as there’s a new message.

What's your legal question?