Can I make a repair shop pay if my car gets wrecked while they have it?
Full conversation
I own a 1986 911 car and took it to the mechanic shop for work. During the vehicle inspection, they worked on the car, and it seems that something happened to the ignition. When the mechanic took it for a test drive, the car turned off, something that never happened before. While waiting for the tow truck, a distracted uninsured driver rear-ended it. What can I do?
I’m sorry to hear about the unfortunate situation with your car. Can you tell me if you have already contacted your insurance company regarding the accident?
No, because it was in the shop’s possession, they have to contact their garage keeper’s insurance.
Have you discussed the ignition issue with the mechanic, and do you have any documentation of the work they performed?
It was still in the inspection phase.
Is there anything else the lawyer should know before I connect you? Rest assured they’ll be able to help with your car accident.
No.
Good day and welcome. Please give me a moment to review your question. I do not provide representation, and no attorney-client relationship is formed. My answers and comments should not be considered legal advice. It is always best to hire a local attorney to review the specifics of your particular case to ensure that a proper review is conducted.
Any other recent developments?
I’m waiting for the shop’s insurance and representatives to talk to me. My car is still at their shop.
Based on the facts you have described, there may be multiple potentially responsible parties, and it is important not to assume that only the uninsured driver is liable. The first issue is whether the repair shop had legal custody of your vehicle at the time of the accident. Generally, when a vehicle is left with a repair facility for inspection or repair, a bailment is created, meaning the shop has a duty to exercise reasonable care while the vehicle is in its possession. If the vehicle unexpectedly stalled because of something that occurred during the inspection or because the shop’s employees disturbed or damaged the ignition system, that fact could become significant. If the vehicle was disabled as a result of the shop’s negligence and was consequently left in a vulnerable location where it was struck, you may have an argument that the shop’s conduct contributed to the loss. At the same time, the distracted uninsured driver remains potentially liable for negligently rear-ending the vehicle, regardless of whether the Porsche had stalled. Determining whether the shop bears any legal responsibility will likely depend on the circumstances surrounding the inspection, whether they had begun working on the ignition or related systems, where the vehicle was located when it stalled, and whether reasonable precautions were taken after it became disabled.
You should also promptly notify your own automobile insurance carrier, even if the repair shop has stated that it intends to report the incident to its garage keeper’s insurer. Reporting the loss to your own insurer helps protect your rights and ensures that applicable coverages, such as collision or uninsured motorist property damage (where available), are preserved if there is later a dispute between the insurers. You should ask the repair shop to preserve all inspection notes, photographs, diagnostic reports, work orders, and any internal communications regarding the vehicle, particularly anything documenting the ignition issue or the circumstances leading to the breakdown. If the police investigated the collision, obtain the police report as well. Because the vehicle is a 1986 Porsche 911, which may have substantial collector or classic-car value, it is also important to document its pre-loss condition with maintenance records, photographs, appraisals, or valuation evidence. If the vehicle is ultimately repaired, you may also have a claim for any diminution in value if the accident materially affects its market value despite repairs.
Finally, if the repair shop denies responsibility by asserting that it was only performing an inspection and had not yet begun repairs, that does not necessarily end the legal analysis. The question is not simply whether repairs had commenced but whether the shop exercised reasonable care while the vehicle was entrusted to it and whether any act or omission on its part was a contributing cause of the accident or the resulting damages. Likewise, the uninsured driver’s lack of insurance does not eliminate that driver’s legal liability for the collision, although it may affect the practical ability to recover damages directly from that individual. Depending on the evidence, liability could ultimately rest entirely with the distracted driver, entirely with the repair shop if its negligence caused the vehicle to become disabled in a dangerous location, or be shared between both parties under the comparative fault principles applicable in many jurisdictions. For that reason, it is important to preserve all evidence now and avoid authorizing repairs or disposal of damaged parts until the insurers have had an opportunity to inspect the vehicle and determine how the ignition issue and the collision are related.
The car is a collector car, rest of the world, federalized and legalized for the 50 states. It is an original car, never crashed. The importance of the car is that it was original, in mint condition with 75k miles. Now, even if they fix it, it has a huge loss in value. Plus, I do not want a car that was crashed.
Thanks.
Best of luck to you, my friend.
Disclaimer
By messaging FreeLegalAdvice.com, you agree to our Terms and have read our Privacy Policy.
The information provided on AskaLawyer.com is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and timeliness of the information presented, we make no guarantees regarding its completeness or applicability to your specific circumstances.
Use of this website does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and FreeLegalAdvice.com or any of its attorneys. Communications through this website, including any responses from attorneys, are not privileged or confidential. For advice tailored to your individual situation, we recommend consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
FreeLegalAdvice.com disclaims any liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this site. We are not responsible for any third-party content that may be accessed through this website. Reliance on any information provided herein is solely at your own risk.