[FL] Can a trucking company charge a driver for damages when it ordered the driver to complete a load they were not trained for?
Full conversation
I am seeking legal advice regarding a disputed $5,000 fuel-spill charge that my former company assessed against me. At this stage, I am only asking about the $5,000 fuel-spill issue, not any other accounting disputes. Here are the facts:
- I was hired to haul chassis and cutaway vans on a specialized lowboy trailer. That is my background and training. I am not a traditional flatbed or heavy-haul driver.
- I had never loaded a large vac truck like the one involved in this incident.
- Before attempting the load, I told management I was not comfortable because I had never been trained to load that type of equipment by myself. I wanted to wait until the following morning so I would have sufficient time and daylight.
- My contract states that the carrier agrees to provide on-the-job training with the owner until the driver is comfortable loading cargo.
- The owner of the truck I drove also objected to me doing this load because I lacked experience with this type of equipment. I believe he later agreed that I should not have been responsible for the resulting $5,000 fuel-spill charge, although I am still searching my records to see whether I have that specific conversation in writing.
- I was instructed to proceed anyway and was told I would be talked through the process over the phone.
- I successfully loaded the vac truck onto the trailer without damaging it.
- The auction yard then informed me they were closing and required me to leave. They would not allow me to leave the equipment overnight or return later to finish securing it.
- While backing the vac truck off the trailer so I could leave, the wooden support blocks under the ramps sank several inches into wet ground after heavy rain. That sudden drop caused the fuel tank to contact the trailer and damage a fitting, resulting in a diesel fuel spill.
- I have photographs showing the ground failure, the support blocks sinking, the truck position, and the resulting fuel spill. I also have call logs showing I was communicating with company personnel during the incident.
- A claims employee also told me she did not believe I should have to pay this charge, although I am still looking to see whether I have that statement documented in writing.
My questions are:
- Based on these facts, does it appear I may have a strong basis to dispute the $5,000 fuel-spill charge?
- Does the contract language about on-the-job training until the driver is comfortable loading cargo appear legally significant?
- Would you recommend first trying to resolve this directly with the company, or pursuing another legal process?
- Are there any additional documents or evidence you recommend I gather before taking further action?
I appreciate any guidance you can provide.
I understand how stressful it can be to deal with a disputed charge like this, especially when you feel unprepared for the task. Can you tell me if you have already attempted to resolve this issue directly with your former company?
Not formally. I raised my concerns before and after the incident. Before attempting the load, I told management I was not comfortable because I had never been trained to load that type of equipment by myself and wanted to wait until the following morning. I was instructed to proceed anyway. After the incident, I discussed the matter with the truck owner and company personnel. The truck owner believed I should not have been responsible for the $5,000 fuel-spill charge, and a claims employee also told me she did not believe I should have to pay it. I am currently gathering my documents to determine what I have in writing. I have not yet submitted a formal written challenge specifically addressing the $5,000 fuel-spill charge because I first wanted to understand my legal rights and whether I have a valid basis to dispute it.
Have you gathered any written documentation or evidence, such as emails or texts, that support your claims about the training and instructions you received?
Yes. I have gathered several pieces of written evidence, including text messages, photographs, call logs, and my employment contract. The written evidence includes:
- Text messages from the day of the incident.
- Text messages showing I was communicating with the truck owner regarding the load.
- Photographs documenting the loading process, the support blocks sinking into the wet ground, the truck position, and the resulting fuel spill.
- Call logs showing I attempted to contact company personnel during the incident.
- My employment contract, which includes a provision regarding on-the-job training until the driver is comfortable loading cargo.
Some of the most important conversations occurred by telephone or in person rather than by text. I am continuing to search my records for any additional written communications that document those conversations.
Is there anything else the Lawyer should know before I connect you? Rest assured they’ll be able to help with your fuel-spill charge.
Yes. One important fact is that this was not simply an accident during a routine load. Before the incident, I told management that I had never loaded this type of equipment before, that I was not comfortable doing it by myself, and that I wanted to wait until the following morning. I was instructed to proceed anyway and was told I would be talked through it over the phone. The truck owner also objected to me performing this load because it was outside my experience. After the incident, he told me he did not believe I should be responsible for the $5,000 fuel-spill charge. A claims employee also told me she did not believe I should have to pay that charge. I am continuing to search my records for any written documentation of those conversations. My goal at this time is not to pursue every dispute I have with the company. I am specifically seeking legal guidance on whether the $5,000 fuel-spill charge appears to be valid based on the facts, my contract, and the evidence I have collected, and what the best way to challenge that charge would be if it is not.
Hi there! Welcome to our service. My name is Liz and I’ve been an attorney for more than a decade, and I am here to assist with your legal concerns. No attorney-client relationship is formed from our conversation. So I can best help, does your contract mention anything about your liability?
Yes. The contract contains provisions regarding liability, but I believe they need to be interpreted in the context of the facts. I have the contract available and can provide the relevant sections if needed. My concern is that I was assigned a task I had never been trained to perform. I told management I was not comfortable hauling and securing a vacuum truck because my experience was limited to hauling chassis and cutaway vans on a specialized lowboy. I attempted to contact the owner before proceeding but could not reach him, and I was instructed to continue anyway. I’m trying to determine whether, under these circumstances and the language of the contract, I can legally be held responsible for the approximately $5,000 fuel spill cleanup charge.
I need to correct one factual point in my previous message. I misspoke when I said I was unable to reach the owner. I did speak with the owner before attempting the load. I told him I was not comfortable because I had never been trained to load that type of equipment. He also objected to me doing that load because of my lack of experience with that type of equipment, but I was ultimately instructed to proceed anyway. I wanted to make sure the facts were accurate.
Which that’s where the liability clause can come in as it’s one factor. However, the fact the owner said not to do it, and then you were told to do it anyway is definitely a factor that goes towards not being liable. As does the clause stating that you will be actually trained before you will be made to move a load. Also, with the ground, did anyone notice the mud was causing an issue before the platform started sinking?
No. I was alone at the auction yard attempting to load the vac truck. The owner of the company encouraged me to proceed with the load and tried to talk me through it over the phone. The owner of the truck I was driving for did not think I should be doing that load because I had never been trained to load that type of equipment, and I shared that concern. I told them I was not comfortable attempting it by myself and wanted to wait until the following morning. It had rained earlier, so the ground was wet, but I had no reason to believe the wooden support blocks would sink several inches into the ground. The failure occurred when I was backing the truck off the trailer because the auction yard was closing and required me to leave. As the weight of the rear axle crossed over the support blocks, they suddenly sank into the wet ground, causing the rear of the truck to drop enough for the fuel tank to contact the trailer and damage the fitting. I have photographs documenting the support blocks after they sank, the position of the truck, and the resulting fuel spill.
Thanks for clarifying that. That can be an important factor because but for those blocks sinking, the spill may not have occurred which is also more an act of god with the ground being wet.
Thank you for your feedback so far. I appreciate it. Please let me know if there are any additional facts or documents you would like me to provide so you can better evaluate whether the $5,000 fuel-spill charge is legally supportable.
What does the liability clause say?
The liability clause states, in relevant part, that I am liable for cargo claims occurring while the cargo is in my possession or under my control that relate to or arise out of my solely negligent performance of the contract. My question is whether that clause applies under these facts. My position is that I was assigned a type of load I had never been trained to perform, I expressed that I was not comfortable doing it by myself, the owner of the truck also objected to me doing the load, and I was instructed to proceed anyway. In addition, the contract also contains a provision stating that I would receive on-the-job training with the owner until I was comfortable loading cargo. Those are the facts I’m trying to determine the legal effect of.
Which in this case, that is helpful, because you can argue at the very least you were not solely negligent as you were bullied into taking the load and into leaving before you were ready.
Thank you. That is very helpful. Based on what I’ve told you, would your recommendation be to first present my evidence and request that the company remove the $5,000 fuel-spill charge, or would you recommend pursuing another legal process first? Also, based on the facts I’ve shared, do you believe I have a reasonably strong basis for challenging that charge?
Before pursuing legal action presenting your evidence to the company in a formal letter or meeting and discussing a settlement and removal of the charge. You do have a good basis for challenging, legal action is just meant to be the last resort.
Thank you. Could you explain in more detail why you believe I have a reasonably strong basis for challenging the charge? Based on the facts I’ve shared and the terms of my contract, what are the strongest legal arguments in my favor, and what do you see as the weakest parts of my case that the company is likely to rely on? If you were representing me, what evidence and documentation would you prioritize presenting to maximize the likelihood that the company removes the charge without litigation?
So I cannot go into strategy as we can only provide information. However, the fact the contract says “solely based on your negligence” when talking about liability is a key point. As does the fact that it said you would be trained. You were not trained, and you made it clear you were not trained and tried to refuse. The owner also said don’t do it, and they forced you to anyway.
Florida also follows a comparative fault system under Section 768.81, Florida Statutes, which reflects the general principle that responsibility for a loss can be divided among the parties according to each one’s share of fault. In addition, if your contract is a lease of equipment with a motor carrier, federal truth-in-leasing rules at (49 CFR § 376.12(j)(3)) require the lease to clearly specify the conditions under which deductions for cargo or property damage may be made, and require the carrier to give a written explanation and itemization before any such deduction is taken.
Thank you. That explanation is very helpful. If you were reviewing this matter for the company, what arguments do you think they would most likely make to defend the $5,000 charge despite the training provision, the “sole negligence” language, and the facts I’ve described? Also, based on what I’ve told you, is there any additional evidence or documentation you think would significantly strengthen my position before I present this to the company?
They will likely rely on the fact that despite not being trained and initially refusing, you did still do it, rather than refusing further and leaving the cargo. So having a defense for that can be important. If you can get statements from anyone who witnessed it, that could also be helpful.
Thank you. That is helpful. I do believe there are several people with firsthand knowledge of the events. The owner of the company, a company employee who was involved in directing the load, the owner of the truck I was driving, and an employee from the claims department all have personal knowledge of different parts of what occurred before, during, or after the incident. Would those individuals generally be considered relevant fact witnesses because of their firsthand knowledge, even if some of them work for or are associated with the company?
Yes, those individuals would generally be considered relevant fact witnesses and even if they are associated with the company, their testimonies can provide valuable insights into what happened and support your case.
Thank you. I really appreciate your time and insight. Based on everything we’ve discussed, if you were in my position, would you feel comfortable moving forward by first presenting a formal written challenge to the company requesting removal of the $5,000 charge before considering litigation? Or do you believe there is any significant legal issue or missing evidence that I should address first? I want to make sure I approach this professionally and give the company a fair opportunity to resolve the matter before considering any further action.
I think you’re on the right track by considering a formal written challenge to the company first. Presenting your evidence and giving them a chance to resolve the matter amicably is a professional approach. You seem well-prepared with the evidence and facts you’ve gathered, and this step could potentially lead to a resolution without the need for litigation. Even with strong facts on your side litigation is also always a risk.
One final question. Part of the reason I’m asking is that resolving this $5,000 fuel-spill issue may affect other accounting disputes between me and the former company. Without getting into those other issues, would that change your recommendation about my next step? In other words, would you still recommend that I first present a formal written challenge to the company regarding the $5,000 charge, or, because the outcome of this issue could affect other disputes, would you recommend consulting or retaining an attorney before contacting the company?
Since I don’t know about the other disputes, hiring a local attorney in that case would be a good idea, just so the full picture is considered.
Thank you very much for your time and for taking the time to go through the facts with me. Your explanations regarding the contract language, the training provision, the “sole negligence” clause, and the importance of the factual circumstances have been very helpful. I appreciate your recommendation to organize my evidence, present a formal written challenge regarding the $5,000 fuel-spill charge, and consult a local attorney to evaluate the broader issues before taking any further action. Thank you again for your assistance.
I’m glad I could help! If you have any other questions or need further assistance, feel free to reach out.
One last question. Because the incident, the loading, and the fuel spill all occurred in Florida, would you recommend that I consult with a Florida attorney rather than an attorney in my home state?
Yes, consulting with a Florida attorney would be beneficial since the incident occurred there.
Thank you.
You’re very welcome.
Disclaimer
By messaging FreeLegalAdvice.com, you agree to our Terms and have read our Privacy Policy.
The information provided on AskaLawyer.com is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and timeliness of the information presented, we make no guarantees regarding its completeness or applicability to your specific circumstances.
Use of this website does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and FreeLegalAdvice.com or any of its attorneys. Communications through this website, including any responses from attorneys, are not privileged or confidential. For advice tailored to your individual situation, we recommend consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
FreeLegalAdvice.com disclaims any liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this site. We are not responsible for any third-party content that may be accessed through this website. Reliance on any information provided herein is solely at your own risk.