[NY] Can a tenant cancel a signed lease after learning of a building rule that was not disclosed before signing?
Full conversation
Overview: I signed a condo lease in NYC that I’m backing out of. I spent a great deal of time researching and trying to make sure I had everything right. The condo has a strict ban that wasn’t disclosed to me when I mentioned my scooter a couple of times during the tour and when dropping off checks. The ban isn’t mentioned in the lease or board package. I didn’t think I needed to ask about a ban I didn’t know existed, and I assumed my scooter would be allowed based on verbal communications and the materials I signed. I just can’t think of what else I could have done. I feel misled.
Rule #10 in the rules and regulations of the board package says that scooters are allowed in designated elevators: “No bicycles, scooters or similar vehicles shall be allowed in any of the elevators other than the elevators designated by the Condominium board or the managing agent of the Condominium for that purpose.” I read that and made a note to ask which elevator I should use to transport my scooter when moving in.
May 21: I toured the apartment. During the tour, I told the agent I have a scooter I use to get around. When asked if my scooter would fit in the elevator, he told me I’d probably use the other elevator for scooter transport. He showed me a bike room and tried to show me another (security didn’t see him this time), saying I could park it there. The first room was full, and I told him I could just leave it in my unit.
May 28: I dropped off the checks for processing fees. I told him I’d come up the freight elevator because I have a scooter. He said he’d just meet me outdoors since he didn’t know where the freight elevator was. I asked a couple of questions while I had my scooter with me. I don’t have any written proof of my disclosures and inquiries about the scooter, only verbal communications during the tour and the in-person meeting.
May 29: Signed lease.
May 31: Rental taken off the market.
June 1: Approval message.
June 10: I visited to take some measurements. I brought my scooter this time and found out for the first time that the board has a strict scooter ban. They offered to let me store it in a shed outside, but that is unrealistic for daily storage and use. The scooter cannot fit in the locked compartment even when folded. I left my scooter there for an hour during that visit, and it was covered in dust after only an hour. There is construction, I experienced respiratory irritation from heavy dust days later, prolonged exposure to weather creates an actual fire hazard, and I cannot charge it outside. We started discussing exiting the lease.
June 11: I wrote a letter that the agent forwarded to the board. I gave it my best for the board to reconsider or grant an exception based on my circumstances. The request was rejected.
June 12: Phone call discussing their termination terms:
Lease termination.
Refund of the $3,200 security deposit.
Refund of $3,200 first month’s rent.
Refund of $1,600 prorated rent.
Retention of the $250 and $500 processing fees.
Responsibility for rent from June 15 until the next tenant moves in.
They changed this from “you would need to forfeit all,” and then from a minimum of $3,200 first month’s rent and $3,200 one-month security deposit (texts on June 10).
June 13: They confirmed their termination terms by text: “Unfortunately this is the absolute minimum she would consider as far as a return. You’re under contract for a full year’s worth of rent. This will in turn cost the owner loss and she will not cover that loss given the contract.” I asked if there is a limit or cap on future rent liability, and they said, “Unfortunately not but we would make every effort to rent it asap” and “It will have to go through the board again.” I asked them to send over the official lease termination.
June 14 (today): I have no keys or physical possession of the apartment, and I do not plan to move in or go through with the lease. I’m still waiting on their official termination.
June 15: Move-in date.
Questions:
- Where does this stand legally, and does their offer make sense? I have been careful not to mention any legal terms or lease rescission yet, and this has been more of a friendly negotiation so far. I’m worried that if I bring it up, they may retract their offer or the tone might become aggressive.
- Please let me know if I have a good chance at lease rescission, or if this is a situation where both parties did nothing wrong from a legal standpoint. If I don’t have a good chance at rescission, I would want to negotiate more and at least split the vacancy rent or get a cap, because there is a possibility of me paying indefinite rent under their current proposal.
- Is there a cooling-off period? I asked them to send over their lease termination terms, but they might be stalling, especially since tomorrow is when my contract starts.
It sounds like you’re in a challenging situation, and I understand how frustrating this must be for you. Have you already communicated your concerns about the scooter ban to the landlord or property management?
Yes.
Have you documented all your communications regarding the scooter and the lease terms, including any texts or emails?
Some of them, not all yet.
Is there anything else the Lawyer should know before I connect you? Rest assured they’ll be able to help with your lease termination.
That’ll be it for now.
Hello and thank you for your question. My name is Legal Eagle and I will be assisting you today.
Generally speaking, your strongest argument is that the scooter ban was not adequately disclosed despite your repeated references to the scooter before signing the lease (Mandarin Trading Ltd. v. Wildenstein, 16 N.Y.3d 173 (2011)).
The refund offer is relatively favorable, but the unlimited future rent liability is the provision that would concern me most (N.Y. Real Property Law § 227-e).
Generally speaking, there is no automatic cooling-off period for a residential lease in New York (N.Y. Personal Property Law § 427).
When you say that the refund offer is favorable, what do you mean?
What I mean is that, in many lease-break situations, landlords take the position that the tenant remains liable for the full lease and may initially refuse to return prepaid rent or deposits.
Here, they appear willing to return the security deposit, first month’s rent, and prorated rent, while only retaining the processing fees.
The part of the proposal that concerns me is the uncapped future rent obligation if the unit is not re-rented promptly.
That is why I view the refund portion as relatively favorable, while the ongoing rent liability remains the more significant issue.
For other lease-break situations, are you referring to ones similar to mine? I haven’t moved in or gotten the keys, and I signed based on misleading documents and conversations. From my perspective (and I could totally be wrong), I’m essentially paying for their mistakes and they will take no losses. I did sign a legally binding contract, and I fully intended to commit to it until I discovered a rule that was not disclosed to me or included in the lease I signed. If I had known in any way that scooters were banned, I would not have moved forward with my application.
Generally speaking, I was referring to lease-break situations in general, not specifically situations involving alleged nondisclosure or misleading statements.
Based on the facts you have described, your position is stronger than that of a tenant who simply changes their mind after signing.
Your argument is that you disclosed the scooter issue repeatedly, received responses that reasonably suggested it would not be a problem, and only learned of the ban after signing the lease.
That is why the potential rescission argument exists here. Whether it ultimately succeeds is a separate question, but the facts you described are more favorable than a typical lease-break case.
Given that it’s not a typical lease-break case, would you still say that their offer is favorable? It feels like they’re treating my case as a typical lease break. From a fairness or blame standpoint, I don’t think it would be fair for me to pay anything other than the processing fees (since that service has been done), but please let me know how this reads legally or to a landlord.
Generally speaking, your position is stronger than a typical lease-break case because you are claiming nondisclosure, not simply a change of mind.
From a legal standpoint, they are still treating it largely as a lease-break situation, which is why they are seeking continued rent liability.
My primary concern remains the uncapped future rent obligation. The refund terms are less concerning than that provision.
Are you saying it would make sense for me to be liable for capped future rent?
Not necessarily.
If your rescission argument is correct, then your position would be that you should not owe future rent at all.
I mentioned a cap only because settlement negotiations are different from legal liability.
If you decide to compromise rather than fight over rescission, a cap would be far preferable to unlimited rent liability.
My concern is the unlimited liability, not the idea of a cap itself.
I managed to negotiate a cap of 3 weeks. It’s not ideal, but I’ll take your advice and settle with this.
Thank you so much, that’ll be all my questions.
You’re welcome.
Disclaimer
By messaging FreeLegalAdvice.com, you agree to our Terms and have read our Privacy Policy.
The information provided on AskaLawyer.com is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and timeliness of the information presented, we make no guarantees regarding its completeness or applicability to your specific circumstances.
Use of this website does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and FreeLegalAdvice.com or any of its attorneys. Communications through this website, including any responses from attorneys, are not privileged or confidential. For advice tailored to your individual situation, we recommend consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
FreeLegalAdvice.com disclaims any liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this site. We are not responsible for any third-party content that may be accessed through this website. Reliance on any information provided herein is solely at your own risk.