[NY] Can I get out of a lease if I was never told about a scooter ban?
Full conversation
I signed a lease in New York City that does not explicitly ban or allow scooters. Rule 10 of the board package says no bicycles, scooters, or similar vehicles may be used in any elevators other than the ones designated by the condominium board or managing agent. I noted that and planned to ask which elevator to use to move my scooter in. A strict ban was never disclosed to me, even though I mentioned my scooter several times during the tour and when dropping off checks. I do not have written proof, only verbal discussions. During the tour I told the agent I use a scooter to get around. When I asked if it would fit in the elevator, he said I would probably use the other elevator. I told him I could just leave it in my unit. When I dropped off checks, I rode my scooter to his office and we talked while I had it with me. I found out about the strict ban for the first time when I visited the apartment after signing and paying, but before move-in. I have no keys or possession.
They offered storage in an outdoor shed, but it is unrealistic for daily use. The scooter does not fit in the locked compartment even when folded, it was covered in dust after one hour, and I cannot charge it outside. The board rejected my letter and offer to reconsider. We are now discussing lease termination. By phone and text, they are offering a refund of the $3,200 security deposit, $3,200 first month’s rent, and $1,600 prorated rent. They would keep $250 and $500 in processing fees. I would owe rent until the next tenant moves in. Where does this stand legally, and does their offer make sense? Key dates: May 29 I signed the lease, May 31 the rental was taken off the market, June 1 I received an approval message, June 15 is the move-in date, and today is June 14. Is there a cooling off period? I do not intend to move in or take possession.
I understand how frustrating this situation must be for you, especially after putting in so much effort to ensure everything was in order. Can you confirm if you have any written communication regarding your inquiries about the scooter during the leasing process?
No.
Have you received any formal documentation from the landlord or management regarding the lease termination and their proposed refund?
Not yet, they are working on it.
Is there anything else the Lawyer should know before I connect you? Rest assured they’ll be able to help with your lease termination.
Yes.
Hi there, thank you for your question. I’m Seth, a Lawyer here on our service, and I’m already reviewing the details of your question to find the best solution for you right away. I understand you’re dealing with a situation where you’re discussing lease termination due to a scooter ban that wasn’t disclosed. Could you tell me more about any specific actions you’ve taken or any other concerns you have?
What do you mean by specific actions? My concern is that I am essentially paying for their mistakes. I am also worried that bringing up legal terminology or lease rescission may be seen as a threat and they could retract their offer. I also do not want to bring it up if I have a bad chance.
I understand your concern about the potential repercussions of bringing up legal terms. Have you received any written communication or formal agreement from the landlord regarding the lease termination and refund offer? This will help us understand the current standing of your discussions.
The agent confirmed their offer via text yesterday and said he would send it over later. I am worried they might be stalling because my move-in date and lease start is tomorrow.
Got it, thanks for sharing that. In the text message you received, did they mention any specific terms or conditions related to the refund or lease termination? This will help us assess the situation more clearly.
The terms are lease termination, a refund of the $3,200 security deposit, a refund of the $3,200 first month’s rent, a refund of $1,600 prorated rent, retention of $250 plus $500 in processing fees, and responsibility for rent from June 15 until the next tenant moves in.
Based on your situation, several legal theories may be relevant. New York landlords and their agents generally have a duty to disclose material facts that could affect a tenant’s decision to rent a property, and a previously undisclosed scooter ban may qualify if it significantly impacts your intended use of the premises. If the restriction substantially interferes with your ability to use and enjoy the property, you may also have an argument under the implied covenant of quiet enjoyment. Additionally, if the lease negotiations included misleading statements or omitted important information about the scooter restriction, there may be a claim for misrepresentation that could affect the enforceability of the lease. Finally, New York consumer protection laws may provide remedies if the failure to disclose the scooter ban constitutes an unfair or deceptive practice. Let me know if you have any questions or clarifications, and if not, I’ll move forward with guidance.
It does substantially impact my daily life, as it is my primary mode of transportation. My Dad is involved and he plans to bring up lease rescission this morning, before bringing up anything legal that might make them retract their offer. Should we push for an official lease termination before tomorrow?
It’s understandable to be cautious about how to proceed, especially with the move-in date approaching. Here is a structured approach to help you navigate this situation:
- Get the offer in writing. Obtain written confirmation of all terms before proceeding with further discussions.
- Address lease termination. Seek a formal lease termination before the move-in date to avoid future obligations or disputes.
- Use careful language. Frame the discussion as a mutual resolution rather than immediately using legal terms that may escalate the situation.
- Evaluate the proposal. Review whether the refund terms, fees, and any continuing rent obligations are fair and negotiable.
Please let me know if you have further questions.
By in writing, does a text count, or would it have to be a document via email? This is the text. Me: “Just to make sure I remember correctly, could you confirm the owner has proposed these? Lease termination, refund of the $3,200 security deposit, refund of the $3,200 first month’s rent, refund of $1,600 prorated rent, retention of $250 plus $500 in processing fees, responsibility for rent from June 15 until the next tenant moves in.” Agent: “Essentially yes, we would refund the money minus the days lost from June 15th once we have a new tenant. The application fees would not be refunded.”
Text counts as writing. Please let me know if you have any further questions.
A text message can serve as a form of written communication, but for more formal matters like lease termination, it’s often better to have a more official document, such as an email or a signed agreement. This provides clearer evidence of the terms agreed upon. Please let me know if you have any other questions.
Should I wait for them to send over an official document before asking my Dad to negotiate more or push for a lease rescission?
It’s a good idea to wait for the official document before proceeding with any further negotiations or discussions about lease rescission. Having everything clearly documented will provide a solid foundation for any further actions you or your Dad might want to take. Please let me know if you have further questions.
Okay, got it. Would you suggest I push for a lease rescission, and what are the chances of that for my case? They initially said I would need to forfeit all, and then said a minimum of $3,200 first month’s rent and $3,200 security deposit (texts).
I would not lead with a demand for lease rescission at this stage. While the undisclosed scooter ban, your discussions about the scooter during the leasing process, and the fact that you discovered the restriction before taking possession may give you leverage, rescission is a legal remedy rather than an automatic right. A better approach is to first obtain the formal written termination proposal, preserve your negotiating position, and focus on eliminating or reducing the requirement that you continue paying rent until a new tenant is found. The fact that the landlord has already moved from demanding forfeiture of all funds to offering a substantial refund suggests they may recognize some risk in their position and could be open to further negotiation. If discussions stall, you can then raise the argument that the undisclosed scooter restriction materially affected your decision to rent the apartment and may support a stronger legal position. Please let me know if you have further questions.
From your standpoint, do you think I should eliminate or reduce the requirement to continue to pay rent? In other words, who is at fault? If from a legal perspective no one is at fault, I would think it is fair if we split the rent, for example. And if I do decide on lease rescission eventually, what are the chances I have for that?
From a practical standpoint, I would try to eliminate or significantly reduce the requirement that you continue paying rent until a new tenant is found. Based on the facts you’ve described, this situation appears to stem from an undisclosed restriction that materially affects your primary mode of transportation, rather than a simple change of mind on your part. While that does not necessarily mean the landlord is legally at fault, it gives you leverage to argue that you should not bear all of the financial consequences.
New York law also supports that approach. Under Real Property Law Section 227-e, a residential landlord generally must take reasonable steps to re-rent the unit after a tenant leaves, and a lease generally cannot waive that duty, which supports pushing back on an open-ended rent obligation. General Business Law Section 349 prohibits deceptive acts and practices, which is the consumer protection angle for an undisclosed restriction. Real Property Law Section 238-a limits the fees a landlord may charge applicants and tenants, so it is worth checking whether the retained $250 and $500 processing fees are permitted.
I would focus first on obtaining a written lease termination agreement with a full refund of the rent and security deposit, and at most a reasonable retention of the application or processing fees, rather than accepting an open-ended rent obligation. As for lease rescission, I believe you have a credible argument because you discussed the scooter during the leasing process, the agent’s comments arguably suggested scooter use would be permitted, and you discovered the ban before taking possession. However, because those discussions were not documented in writing, I would view rescission as a potentially persuasive negotiating position rather than a guaranteed legal outcome. For that reason, securing a favorable written termination agreement may be the better immediate objective, while preserving rescission as a fallback argument if negotiations break down.
The agent is not admitting to it by text, but I managed to get a recording of a phone call that does not fully line up with my story, though it is still something. The agent said: “I’m doing so many tours during the day. I know we went to the basement and we happened to pass the bike room, and I imagined what I said was something along the lines of ‘I don’t see why not, you could keep it in there,’ but it was never really made clear how necessary your scooter was and it just didn’t really register for me.” Also, some AI lawyers told me that verbal assurances are fully admissible for fraudulent inducement, and that even an innocent misrepresentation is sufficient for rescission. Is this true?
Verbal assurances can indeed play a role in cases of fraudulent inducement, especially if they were relied upon in making a decision. In New York, even an innocent misrepresentation can sometimes be grounds for rescission if it materially affects the agreement. However, proving fraudulent inducement typically requires showing that the misrepresentation was intentional or reckless, and that you relied on it to your detriment. Your recording could support your case by demonstrating that there was some acknowledgment of the scooter discussion, even if it doesn’t fully align with your story. It’s important to consider how this evidence fits into the broader context of your negotiations and any written agreements. If you decide to pursue this angle, it might be beneficial to consult with a local attorney who can provide specific guidance based on all the details of your situation. Please let me know if you have further questions.
Ah, okay, got it. I think I will take your advice and try harder on negotiating between us. Thank you so much, this has been very helpful. All-set.
Great! Take care and best of luck to you.
Thank you! You too.
Disclaimer
By messaging FreeLegalAdvice.com, you agree to our Terms and have read our Privacy Policy.
The information provided on AskaLawyer.com is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and timeliness of the information presented, we make no guarantees regarding its completeness or applicability to your specific circumstances.
Use of this website does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and FreeLegalAdvice.com or any of its attorneys. Communications through this website, including any responses from attorneys, are not privileged or confidential. For advice tailored to your individual situation, we recommend consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
FreeLegalAdvice.com disclaims any liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this site. We are not responsible for any third-party content that may be accessed through this website. Reliance on any information provided herein is solely at your own risk.