[CO] Can my landlord charge me for refinishing every floor if I only damaged one room?
Full conversation
I have an ex landlord in Colorado Springs, CO that is keeping my deposit and charging extra which I believe is unlawful.
I understand how frustrating it can be to deal with a landlord over your deposit. Can you tell me how much of your deposit is being withheld and what reasons your landlord has given for the charges?
All of my deposit which is $2850 and asking for an additional,$1399.50. The are claiming the wood floors in the entire home had to be refinished and lots of wall repairs.
Have you already attempted to communicate with your landlord about this issue, and if so, what was their response?
Yes, they said they are not even charging us for everything they could so we need to pay what they are asking or they will charge us for the other stuff.
Is there anything else the Landlord-Tenant Lawyer should know before I connect you? Rest assured they’ll be able to help with your deposit dispute.
No.
Hello and welcome to the site! My name is Barrister and I am a licensed attorney and here to help with your situation. I know your question is important, but there may be a short delay in my responses as I type out an answer or reply as I am typically working with several customers at once on the website. I have read your post and I am sorry to hear you are having to deal with this situation as I realize it can be frustrating and confusing.
Do you have before and after pictures of the dwelling that show the condition of the floors when you moved in and out?
I did not take pictures unfortunately right before moving out but they sent some black and white photos to us after we sent our dispute. Our bed frame did leave deep scratches in the main bedroom and I agree that is not normal wear and tear but they got the whole houses floor redone and are trying to charge us for it.
Thanks for sharing that. Did the landlord provide you with an itemized list of the costs for the floor refinishing and any other repairs? If so, did they send it within 30 days unless the lease states it allows them up to 60?
All they sent in regards to the floor is an estimate they received from a company, not an invoice. The lease says the have 60 days and we are still in that window of time.
In Colorado, a landlord generally cannot charge a tenant for replacing or refinishing flooring beyond the damage the tenant actually caused. The guiding principle is that the landlord is entitled to be made whole, not to receive a better property than before the damage. Colorado law allows a landlord to keep deposit funds only for damage that goes beyond normal wear and tear (CO Rev Stat § 38-12-102). So if you damaged one room’s flooring, and it had to be refinished, the landlord can’t charge you for the entire house...as that puts them in a better position at your expense.
The law states:
The willful retention of a security deposit in violation of this section shall render a landlord liable for treble the amount of that portion of the security deposit wrongfully withheld from the tenant, together with reasonable attorney fees and court costs; except that the tenant has the obligation to give notice to the landlord of his intention to file legal proceedings a minimum of seven days prior to filing said action. (CO Rev Stat § 38-12-103)
That means you have to dispute their claims in writing and tell them if they don’t refund any prorated amounts, you will be filing suit for 3X damages plus costs and attorney fees for willful violation of (CO Rev Stat § 38-12-103).
Additionally, there is the concept of depreciation. For example, if the flooring was 15 years old, you can’t be charged for repair and refinishing of the flooring without accounting for depreciation. Now if the flooring was a year or two old, that means it is essentially new so they could charge for the areas that were damaged.
Ok well there is other stuff too. They are trying to charge us for pest control coming out because mice got in the house and garage (the reason we didn’t renew our lease) and they never solved the issue of how the mice were getting in. I also had to throw away a new couch and recliner because of this. On top of that they are trying to charge us for 26 hours of drywall repair work at $50 per hour when there was maybe 4 hours of work. They updated the home after we left it seems like they are just trying to make some money back.
Understood, so you have other things to dispute with the landlord... in writing... and then if you can’t resolve it, you can file suit in small claims for 3X the amount withheld and the judge will make a determination whether it was justified or not. But it sounds like the landlord is trying to remodel their home on your dime.
Yes, we wrote up a letter and sent it to them certified mail last week disagreeing based on the lack of documentation, inappropriate use of the security deposit beyond reasonable wear and tear with the full floor refinishing, rodent treatment, extensive drywall repair throughout. We stated we would pay for the portions related to our localized damage caused in the bedroom floor, but that we need an itemized receipt for the just our localized repairs needed. Since they only provided a full floor proposal/estimate but there is no proof that the floor have been refinished at all. The online rental listing photos of the house available for rent do not show newer, shiny floors. They responded but did not address a lot of our concerns. Stating there is a list of items they aren’t charging us: yard clean up (they turned the yard into a zero-scape), light bulbs, screen door repairs (although the screen doors have been removed and are no longer there), lots of little stuff, and if we would like they can add that to the existing balance or we can just pay them the $1399.50 they are requesting. They also included the black and white pictures of the move out walk through. We do have annual pictures taken from a rental inspection app where we annually took photos throughout the interior/exterior each year at there request and we were graded on how well we were maintaining the house. Also scored an average 90 out of 100. At this point we have written a second and final attempt letter to amicably resolve them holding all of our security deposit and will let them know they have 7 days to return the partial funds owed or we will file with the court. But we need to add specifics about small claims court and seeking damages up to 3x the amount?
You don’t have to cite the actual law in CO that gives you the right to sue for 3X, but if you did, then that might scare them into settling with you rather than risk having to pay 3X plus costs, and any other damages, like for your couch you had to throw out due to mice.
Okay. What do we need to have prepared for small claims court?
Any pictures you have, any receipts (like for the couch), any communications with the landlord, and your verbal testimony. The odd thing about security deposit cases is that the landlord has to prove their deductions were valid, you don’t have to prove they weren’t. So the burden is shifted to the landlord.
Did you have any other questions about this situation I can help with?
Okay I’ll get a binder. Also our security deposit was technically $1700 with $850 deposit for one pet and then later we got another pet and they charged us $300 for that pet. But they are including those dog deposits with the initial security deposit for a total of $2850 can they do that?
Pet deposits are typically separate from the security deposit and are meant to cover any potential damage caused by the pets. If the lease specifies that the pet deposits are separate, then they should not be included with the security deposit for general damages. If the lease does not clearly separate them, the landlord might try to include them together. However, you can argue that pet deposits should only be used for pet-related damages.
The pet deposit is stated separately on the lease, okay that is good to know. Last question should we send this second letter/final attempt to resolve from us or get a letter specifically from a lawyer as the final attempt?
It would carry more weight coming from a local attorney, but you would probably be looking at 300-500 to hire an attorney to draft a letter for you.
I hope I was able to answer any questions you had about the situation. It was my pleasure to work with you and help with your question. Have a great afternoon and be safe!
Disclaimer
By messaging FreeLegalAdvice.com, you agree to our Terms and have read our Privacy Policy.
The information provided on AskaLawyer.com is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and timeliness of the information presented, we make no guarantees regarding its completeness or applicability to your specific circumstances.
Use of this website does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and FreeLegalAdvice.com or any of its attorneys. Communications through this website, including any responses from attorneys, are not privileged or confidential. For advice tailored to your individual situation, we recommend consulting a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.
FreeLegalAdvice.com disclaims any liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this site. We are not responsible for any third-party content that may be accessed through this website. Reliance on any information provided herein is solely at your own risk.